Walk-In Shower vs. Tub: What Homeowners Regret After Remodeling
Should you keep the bathtub or replace it with a walk-in shower?
It's one of the most common decisions homeowners face during a bathroom remodel—and one where designing around appearance alone can lead to regret.
A large walk-in shower can make a bathroom feel more open and may be easier to enter than a traditional tub/shower combination. But removing a bathtub can also eliminate something your household actually uses.
The better question isn't “Which one is better?” It's “Which one fits how we use this home now—and how we're likely to use it later?”
The Biggest Mistake: Designing for Looks Alone
Bathroom inspiration photos can make the decision seem easy. Large glass showers photograph well, while a standard bathtub may not feel nearly as exciting. But you're going to live with the bathroom, not just look at it.
Before choosing, think about who uses the bathroom, how often anyone actually takes baths, whether young children are part of the household, mobility needs, cleaning preferences, available space, and how long you expect to stay in the home. A good bathroom remodel should balance appearance with everyday function.
When Homeowners Regret Removing the Tub
Removing a tub can make sense, particularly when nobody in the household uses it. But homeowners may regret the decision when they realize their needs have changed. A bathtub can be useful for bathing young children, soaking, washing certain household items, or simply providing another bathing option. The decision deserves extra thought when you're considering removing the only bathtub in the house. That doesn't automatically mean you should keep it.
Claims that every house must have a bathtub for resale are too broad. Buyers have different priorities, and resale effects depend on the particular home and market. Instead, ask yourself a practical question: If we remove this tub, are we comfortable having no bathtub available?If the answer is no, you have your answer.
When Homeowners Regret Keeping the Tub
The opposite happens too. Some homeowners keep a tub because they believe they're “supposed to,” even though nobody uses it. A tub can occupy valuable floor area, create a higher step-over point, and leave less room for a shower. In a bathroom where space is limited, keeping an unused tub can force compromises elsewhere. If your existing tub has become a place to store shampoo bottles rather than something anyone actually bathes in, that's worth considering.
Walk-In Showers: Pros and Tradeoffs
A well-designed walk-in shower can offer several practical advantages.
Depending on its design, it can provide a more open layout, easier entry, more usable shower space, built-in storage niches, benches, handheld shower heads, and other features tailored to the homeowner.
For homeowners thinking about staying in their home long term, entry height and accessibility may also deserve consideration. But don't assume every walk-in shower is automatically accessible. Curbs, door widths, floor transitions, controls, benches, grab-bar locations, and available maneuvering space all matter.
There are tradeoffs as well. Glass needs cleaning. Larger tiled areas mean more surfaces and grout joints to maintain. And a poorly planned shower can create problems involving water containment, drainage, or usability. The parts you cannot see after construction can be just as important as the tile you can.
Bathtubs: Pros and Tradeoffs
Bathtubs still make sense for many households. They provide an option for soaking and can be particularly useful for families with young children. A separate tub and shower can also work well when the bathroom has enough space to accommodate both without making the layout cramped.
The disadvantage is simple: a tub you never use still consumes space. Some tubs also require stepping over a relatively high side, which may become less convenient as household needs change. This is why the decision shouldn't be based solely on trends.
What About Home Resale?
Homeowners frequently ask whether removing a bathtub will hurt resale value.
There isn't a universal answer. The home's size, number of bathrooms, buyer expectations, local market, and whether another bathtub remains in the house can all matter. A local real estate professional who understands comparable homes can provide market-specific guidance if resale is a major factor in your decision.
What homeowners should avoid is remodeling entirely for an imaginary future buyer while making the bathroom less functional for themselves. If you're staying in the house for years, your own daily use deserves significant weight.
What Affects the Cost?
Converting a bathtub to a walk-in shower isn't simply a matter of removing one fixture and installing another.
Cost can be influenced by:
Demolition
Plumbing changes
Drain location
Shower dimensions
Waterproofing
Tile selection
Shower glass
Niches and benches
Fixtures and controls
Existing conditions discovered after demolition
Flooring and wall repairs
Accessibility features
Applicable permits and inspections
Likewise, adding or relocating a bathtub can require plumbing, framing, tile, flooring, and finish work. That is why homeowners should be cautious about generic bathroom remodeling prices found online. The actual scope matters.
Questions to Ask Before You Decide
Before telling your bathroom remodeling contractor to remove the tub, answer these questions:
Do we actually use this bathtub?
Is this the only bathtub in the house?
Will children regularly use this bathroom?
Are we planning to stay in this home long term?
Would easier shower entry benefit anyone in the household?
How much space will each option require?
What plumbing changes are needed?
What is included in the contractor's proposal?
How will the shower be waterproofed?
What warranty applies to the completed work?
The goal is to make the decision before demolition, not after you've committed to a new layout.
Choosing a Bathroom Remodeling Contractor
Whether you choose a walk-in shower, bathtub, or both, installation quality matters. A beautiful tile installation doesn't compensate for poor planning behind the finished surface. Homeowners should ask prospective contractors about scope, waterproofing, plumbing coordination, change orders, applicable permits, schedule expectations, and warranty coverage. Vague answers are a warning sign.
Like Father Like Son Construction LLC provides bathroom remodeling services in San Marcos, New Braunfels, Wimberley, Kyle, Buda, and Dripping Springs. As a family-run residential construction company with 25+ years of experience, LFLSC is licensed and insured and provides a 2-year workmanship warranty. A successful bathroom remodel isn't about following the latest trend. It's about building a bathroom that works for the people who actually use it.
11. FAQ Section
Is a walk-in shower better than a bathtub?
Neither is automatically better. Walk-in showers can provide easier entry and more shower space, while bathtubs provide soaking and bathing options. The right choice depends on your household and bathroom layout.
Should I remove the only bathtub in my house?
Consider the decision carefully. Think about children, future household needs, your expected time in the home, and potential buyer preferences. If resale is a major concern, get local market advice rather than relying on a blanket rule.
Does replacing a tub with a walk-in shower increase home value?
Remodeling can affect buyer appeal, but there is no universal value increase that applies to every home. Local market conditions and the quality and functionality of the remodel matter.
Are walk-in showers easier for older homeowners?
They can be when designed appropriately, particularly when entry barriers are reduced. However, a shower isn't automatically accessible simply because it is called “walk-in.” Layout and individual mobility needs matter.
What should I ask a contractor about a new tiled shower?
Ask about waterproofing, drainage, plumbing, tile installation, shower glass, ventilation, change orders, applicable permits, schedule, and workmanship warranty.
How long does a tub-to-shower conversion take?
The timeline depends on demolition, plumbing changes, waterproofing, tile, glass, inspections when applicable, material availability, and existing conditions.
Planning a Bathroom Remodel?
Before removing your bathtub or committing to a new walk-in shower, make sure the layout works for your household, your space, and your long-term plans.
Like Father Like Son Construction LLC provides bathroom remodeling services throughout San Marcos, New Braunfels, Wimberley, Kyle, Buda, and Dripping Springs. With 25+ years of experience, licensed and insured operations, and a 2-year workmanship warranty, we help homeowners approach remodeling with careful planning and quality workmanship.
Click the button to request a consultation, or call 512-748-2421 to discuss your bathroom remodeling project.
Comments